Shardul Thakur backs Shreyas Iyer after India’s heavy T20I defeat to New Zealand
India’s 87-run loss to New Zealand in the fourth T20I has renewed scrutiny of captain Shreyas Iyer’s batting form. But all-rounder Shardul Thakur has urged fans not to judge the Indian skipper on the basis of a short run of scores, pointing to the demands of batting in the middle order and the added pressure of captaincy.
Iyer made 22 from 11 deliveries in Auckland, where New Zealand piled up 259 before restricting India to 172 for nine. His contribution was brisk, but it did little to change the course of a chase that required India to maintain an exceptional scoring rate. Across the four innings in New Zealand, Iyer has scored 80 runs. India, however, had already secured the T20I series 3-1 before the fourth match.
Thakur’s defence centres on a point often overlooked in discussions of a batter’s numbers: a No. 4 does not always enter with the freedom to play a set style. The state of the innings, the required run rate and the wickets remaining can all dictate whether the batter must rebuild, accelerate or take risks immediately.
Why the No. 4 role can be difficult in T20 cricket
In T20 cricket, the opening batters generally establish the initial tempo. A middle-order player, by contrast, may arrive after a strong start and be asked to keep the pressure on—or come in early after quick wickets and steady the innings. The same position can call for two very different approaches within the space of a few matches.
Thakur explained that Iyer’s place in the order can also shift. India may send a left-handed batter ahead of him as a tactical move, leaving Iyer to enter at No. 5 rather than his usual No. 4. That adjustment can affect how many balls remain, which bowlers are operating and what the team needs from him.
“Many times, how you bat depends on the match situation, and at the number he bats, he has to react to the situation,” Thakur said on Sony LIV. “He cannot set the momentum. The momentum gets set by the top three batters, but Shreyas Iyer comes at No. 4, and sometimes at No. 5 if the left-hander is sent in as a tactical call.”
That context matters when assessing a batter’s recent form. A scorecard records runs and balls faced, but not always the instructions a player received, the risk level demanded by the situation or the role he was asked to perform. In a format where a few overs can transform a match, those details can make a substantial difference.
Building an innings and finishing it are different challenges
Thakur also highlighted the range of responsibilities attached to Iyer’s role. A middle-order batter may need to assess the scoreboard, settle into the innings, lift the scoring rate and then finish strongly at the death. Those demands require frequent changes in tempo—sometimes within the same innings.
“You have to react based on the situation and the scoreboard. So, it’s not an easy position to bat, and once you get set, you also need death batting,” Thakur said. “It’s a challenge as to how you adapt to the game, set the tempo of your batting, and finish as well. So, he has a lot of responsibility.”
The Auckland match offered a clear example of how the circumstances can shape a batter’s choices. Chasing a target of 260, India needed a rapid start and sustained aggression. Iyer’s 22 from 11 balls reflected an attacking approach, but one short contribution could not compensate for the wider challenge of keeping pace with New Zealand’s total. The result was a difficult team performance, rather than a simple measure of one player’s ability.
Captaincy adds another layer of pressure
Iyer is also carrying the responsibilities of leading India. In T20 cricket, captains must make quick decisions on bowling changes, field placements and tactical match-ups while remaining focused on their own batting. Those duties can be especially demanding in a fast-moving contest, where a single over may alter the game’s direction.
Thakur acknowledged that the added responsibility can influence decision-making, but maintained that Iyer has shown leadership ability. He pointed to Iyer’s record in the Indian Premier League: he led Kolkata Knight Riders to the title and guided Punjab Kings to a final. Those achievements, Thakur suggested, demonstrate that Iyer has experience managing high-pressure teams and adapting to leadership challenges.
“On top of that, he is the captain. That’s an added responsibility for him these days. So, the decision-making can be up and down at times,” Thakur said, adding that Iyer has been showing his captaincy skills while leading India.
What the latest prediction for Iyer’s form should consider
For supporters assessing what may come next, the most useful prediction is not based solely on four innings. T20 form can shift quickly, and a batter’s next opportunity may arrive in a different role or under very different match conditions. Iyer’s response in the remaining fixtures—and the way India’s top order sets up his innings—will offer a clearer indication of his current rhythm.
That does not mean criticism is unwarranted. India will want greater consistency from its middle order, especially when chasing imposing totals. But evaluating Iyer fairly means considering both his recent returns and the demands of his position. A No. 4 may be required to rescue an innings one night and finish a chase the next; a captain must manage those expectations while also making decisions for the team.
Thakur’s message was ultimately one of perspective. T20 cricket is a format of sharp swings, where a few strong or difficult outings can quickly shape public opinion. Rather than drawing a firm conclusion from a brief stretch, India’s management and supporters will be watching how Iyer adapts, contributes and leads as the series progresses.


