Faf du Plessis names Pat Cummins as a more valuable Test player than Marco Jansen
South Africa’s dramatic 2-1 victory over Australia has put Test cricket back in the spotlight—and sparked a debate about what makes a player truly valuable in the longest format. Former Proteas captain Faf du Plessis has weighed in, choosing Australia skipper Pat Cummins over Marco Jansen when asked to identify a current Test cricketer whose all-round contribution makes him especially important to his team.
The choice may surprise fans who watched Jansen dominate the recent series. The tall South African left-armer was named Player of the Series, contributed with both bat and ball, and climbed to the top of the ICC Test rankings for bowlers and all-rounders. But du Plessis’s answer was not a dismissal of Jansen’s achievements. Instead, it reflected a broader question: how should a team measure a player’s value when conditions, roles and match situations are constantly changing?
Why du Plessis selected Cummins
In comments to ESPNcricinfo, du Plessis was asked to compare the value of present-day Test players, with Jansen serving as a reference point. He chose Cummins, highlighting the Australian captain’s ability to contribute in more than one way. For du Plessis, a player who can influence a match across multiple disciplines offers a particularly valuable package in Test cricket.
That emphasis on versatility also shaped his discussion of England batter Harry Brook. Du Plessis praised Brook as a generational talent but said he was basing his decision on players with more than one major skill. The distinction is not necessarily about who is the better specialist. Rather, it considers how many different problems a player can solve for a team over five days.
Cummins is primarily known as a fast bowler, but his leadership and useful lower-order batting add to his overall impact. As captain, he also plays a central role in setting plans, managing workloads and responding when a Test shifts direction. Those responsibilities can be difficult to capture in a simple comparison of runs and wickets, yet they are part of the value du Plessis appears to have considered.
Du Plessis pushes back on the Root comparison
The conversation also turned to whether Jansen could be considered more valuable than England’s Joe Root. Du Plessis quickly rejected that comparison, describing Root as one of the game’s greats. He acknowledged that Jansen is an outstanding Test cricketer but noted that placing him alongside established all-time-level players makes the discussion more complicated.
Du Plessis’s comments underline an important difference between a player’s current impact and their standing across a longer career. Jansen’s recent performances have been exceptional, while Root’s record and sustained influence have made him one of the leading batters of his generation. Comparing them involves more than looking at one series or one set of rankings: their roles are different, and their contributions come in very different forms.
Jansen’s series-winning contribution
Jansen’s case for being among the most valuable players in Test cricket is nevertheless compelling. Across the three-match series against Australia, he took 10 wickets and scored 146 runs. His batting arrived at crucial moments, particularly when South Africa needed resilience from the lower-middle order rather than a quick burst of runs.
One of the defining performances came in the second Test. Jansen scored 82 and claimed five wickets, helping South Africa recover from a difficult position and secure an innings victory. His partnership with captain Temba Bavuma was especially important, giving the visitors a platform at a point when Australia appeared to have the upper hand.
Those contributions show why an all-rounder can be so influential in Test cricket. A lower-order batter who can extend an innings may change the pressure on the opposition, while a bowler capable of taking wickets can turn a match even after spending hours in the field. Jansen’s series combined both qualities, making him central to South Africa’s turnaround and eventual series win.
His performances also brought significant recognition in the ICC rankings. Jansen rose to the top of the Test bowling rankings and became the leading Test all-rounder, ending Ravindra Jadeja’s four-year run at the summit of that category. The rankings do not settle every debate about player value, but they reflect the scale of Jansen’s recent impact across disciplines.
Cummins’ value extends beyond the scorecard
Cummins has long been regarded as one of the leading fast bowlers in Test cricket. His pace, accuracy and ability to generate pressure have helped make him a major force for Australia, and he held the No. 1 position in the Test bowling rankings for an extended period. As captain, he has also led Australia through major international campaigns and taken on the responsibility of guiding a high-profile team.
His recent results, however, have raised questions about Australia’s consistency. The side has experienced setbacks at home, including a defeat to Bangladesh despite having a strong squad available, and it surrendered the advantage in the series against South Africa after winning the opening Test. Those outcomes complicate any assessment of Cummins’s captaincy, although team results alone cannot determine an individual player’s worth.
For Australia, Cummins remains important because his role combines frontline bowling with leadership. But the latest series is a reminder that even an accomplished captain cannot control every variable in a five-day match. Pitch conditions, injuries, batting collapses and opponents’ performances all shape the result, and a player’s influence must be judged within that wider context.
What the debate says about modern Test cricket
The discussion comes at a time when international cricket is increasingly shaped by T20 leagues and shorter formats. Test cricket may receive less attention in some parts of the sporting calendar, but series such as South Africa’s comeback against Australia demonstrate why the format continues to command a loyal audience. Momentum can swing over several days, and a single partnership or spell can transform the outcome.
That complexity also makes the phrase “most valuable player” difficult to define. A specialist batter such as Root may provide consistency and control, while a fast bowler such as Cummins can break partnerships and lead the attack. An all-rounder such as Jansen offers flexibility, allowing a captain to adjust team balance and respond to changing conditions.
Prediction: If Jansen maintains his current level, he is likely to remain a major part of South Africa’s plans and a regular subject in discussions about the world’s leading Test all-rounders. Cummins, meanwhile, will continue to be judged on both his bowling and his leadership as Australia looks to regain consistency. Du Plessis’s selection does not close the debate; it highlights how different kinds of excellence can make players indispensable in different ways.


